When my fourth graders heard Osceola’s words after living through the Second Seminole War in our classroom simulation, the silence was profound. They weren’t just memorizing facts—they were grappling with why wars begin, how policies create conflict, and what it means to understand multiple perspectives.

"Mrs. Zema, this is getting really intense." This observation came from Emma, leader of our Seminole group, as we wrapped up Thursday's session on the Adams-Onís Treaty. Over the past week, my fourth graders had lived through 60 years of territorial changes, wars, and competing claims to Florida—and they were feeling the weight of it all. What started as an exciting competition over land had evolved into something much deeper.

"Wait, WHAT? They just... gave away Florida? Like, the whole thing?" This incredulous question came from Jordan as we examined Treaty of Paris documents. My students had just started the Frontier Struggles simulation, competing for Florida territory. Now they were discovering that while they focused on homesteads and land claims, entire nations had been casually trading Florida back and forth.

"Mrs. Zema, this feels like the most important decision we've made yet." After surviving Drake's attack and Timucua tensions, my fourth graders faced a choice that would define their St. Augustine colony's character. When escaped slaves arrived seeking freedom, the students had to decide: What kind of community did they want to build?

"Before dawn, English privateer Sir Francis Drake launches a surprise raid on the settlement. His ships fire from the sea while his men rush ashore. The Spanish scramble to respond. Smoke fills the air." Twenty-two fourth graders held their breath as I read the event card that would determine their colony's fate. After a week of hurricanes, policy changes, and tough decisions, this was their biggest test yet.

"Mrs. Zema, are we going to die?" This question came from Riley after five days of our Founding St. Augustine simulation. What started with excitement about "getting to be Spanish leaders" had transformed into genuine concern for their colony's survival. Here's how my fourth graders learned that good intentions aren't enough when facing real historical challenges.

"Buenos días, Spanish leaders! Welcome to the year 1565." Twenty-two fourth graders looked around our classroom with curiosity as we began our journey into America's oldest city. Today marked the official start of our Founding St. Augustine simulation—and the mixed reactions were priceless.